The President of the High Priesthood Is Not “the Prophet”

Why D&C 107:64–65 still matters

Latter-day Saints commonly speak of the President of the Church as “the prophet.” The phrase is affectionate, familiar, and now almost automatic. It is also not the title Class 1 scripture gives him.

That is not a small vocabulary problem. It changes what people think a prophet is, what they expect from the President of the Church, and whether the gift of prophecy still belongs to the body of the Saints.

The canon is not flat

When the Nephites asked Jesus a doctrinal question, He did not point them to later commentary. He asked, “Have ye not read the scriptures?” (3 Nephi 27:4–5). Scripture, not subsequent explanation, was the standard.

That standard is not flat. Christ Himself treats scriptural words in different ways. In 3 Nephi 24:1 He commands the people to write “the words which the Father had given unto Malachi”—the Father’s own words. Doctrine and Covenants 1:38 says the same of the Lord’s word: it will not pass away, “whether by mine own voice or by the voice of my servants.” By contrast, Christ calls Isaiah’s prophecy “the words of Isaiah” (3 Nephi 23:1). And 2 Nephi 2:17 shows Lehi offering doctrinal commentary on what was already “written.” The categories appear inside scripture itself. They are not a private ranking invented later.

We can state the hierarchy this way:

Joseph F. Smith applied the same principle when he rejected Adam-God: the Church’s ultimate measure is revelation-based scripture, not subsequent teaching. He did not create the distinction. He used one Christ had already modeled.

The present question is the same kind of collision. In Doctrine and Covenants 107:64–66 the Lord names the office: “he shall be called President of the High Priesthood of the Church; or, in other words, the Presiding High Priest over the High Priesthood of the Church.” That is Divine Words. Calling him “the prophet” as his ordinary title is Human Words—later custom. When the two conflict, the Lord’s wording remains the standard.

What the revelation actually says

Doctrine and Covenants 107 is presented as revelation. In verses 64–66 the Lord says that one must be appointed of the High Priesthood to preside, “and he shall be called President of the High Priesthood of the Church; or, in other words, the Presiding High Priest over the High Priesthood of the Church.”

That is a Class 1 title. It is not a suggestion. It is not public-relations language. It is the name of the office.

The same section also describes other officers by priesthood function: presidents of quorums, bishops, and so on. The pattern is consistent. The Church’s presiding officer is a high priest who presides. He is not given the exclusive personal title “the Prophet” in that revelation.

If we take Class 1 as the standard, the ordinary speech of the Church should follow D&C 107:64–65.

The older convention

The Bible already had a way of speaking about this.

A prophet was a person sent to speak for God. Samuel heard the Lord when “the word of the Lord was precious in those days; there was no open vision” (1 Samuel 3). He was not Eli. Eli was the high priest. Samuel received a call outside that office and was therefore called a prophet.

A high priest held an ordained office. In some periods that office was associated with the gift of prophecy. John’s Gospel records that Caiaphas, “being high priest that year,” spoke a word that the narrator treats as prophecy (John 11:49–51). The point is not that Caiaphas was righteous. The point is the old assumption: the high priest might prophesy by virtue of the office. When that happened, scripture still called him high priest.

The Book of Mormon follows the same convention. The chapter heading to Alma 5 identifies the speaker as “Alma, the High Priest according to the holy order of God,” who then delivers the words to the people in their cities and villages. Alma is not introduced in that heading as “the prophet.” He holds the high-priestly office and speaks from that office. The title that marks his ecclesiastical authority is the priesthood title, even though the speech itself is strongly prophetic in character.

This matches the older biblical pattern: when the gift arrives through or is exercised under priestly office, the person is called by the priesthood title. Samuel is called a prophet because his call came outside the high-priestly office. Eli, Caiaphas, and Alma are identified by their high-priestly office even when they deliver words that carry prophetic force.

Joseph Smith fits the older pattern of a prophet. He reported visions, dictations, and “saith the Lord” revelations before he was the Presiding High Priest. He later also held that office. Those are two facts, not one title.

A later President of the High Priesthood can inherit both. Nothing in the revelation says the prophetic modes died with Joseph. The President may receive visions, dictations, and commandments. When he does, those belong in Class 1 or Class 2, and the Church has a way to receive them as canon.

The ordinary work of the office is different. A High Priest has ecclesiastical authority and pastoral responsibility. In that stewardship he may speak for the good of the flock from what he sees the Church needs: counsel, warning, direction, and encouragement. That speech can be inspired. It is still the speech of a pastor, not automatically the speech of a prophet. A prophet’s main duty is to speak expressly what the Lord commands. The message does not, by itself, carry ecclesiastical authority. It becomes authoritative in the Church only if the messenger also holds priesthood office, or if the Church receives it through the established order.

The older convention kept those duties from being confused:

When members call the President “the prophet” as his ordinary title, they quietly merge the two. Investigators then expect the Joseph Smith pattern—regular dictation of what the Lord commands—from a man whose daily work is pastoral stewardship. Members, meanwhile, hear pastoral counsel as if it were Class 1. Both mistakes come from using one title for two duties.

The canon does not require that merge. D&C 107:64–65 names the office. The prophetic gift remains open, including to the President, and also to sons and daughters who do not preside.

The gift was never meant to be an exclusive brand

Joel said the Lord’s Spirit would be poured out and “your sons and your daughters shall prophesy… your old men shall dream dreams” (Joel 2:28). Peter said that promise had begun to be fulfilled (Acts 2). Paul told the Corinthian church to desire spiritual gifts, “but rather that ye may prophesy” (1 Corinthians 14:1). He treated prophecy as a gift that could be sought and exercised in the congregation, subject to order and testing.

Class 1 and Class 2 texts therefore point in two directions at once:

  1. There is a presiding high priest over the Church.

  2. The gift of prophecy is not confined to that one man.

If “prophet” is reserved as a unique brand name for the President of the Church, both truths are damaged. The office is misnamed. The gift is made to look rare, official, and closed.

That is the opposite of Acts 2.

Why the renamed title causes confusion

Non-members and new members usually meet Joseph Smith first. They hear that a fourteen-year-old asked God, received a vision, and later dictated revelations. “Prophet,” in that story, means what it meant in Samuel’s story: a person who receives and delivers the word of the Lord.

Then they enter the modern Church and hear that “the prophet” is the current President. They reasonably expect the same mode: dictation, “saith the Lord,” frequent addition to the canon. What they usually hear instead is counsel, conference addresses, proclamations, and stewardship. Those things may be inspired. They are still Human Words unless they bear the marks of Divine or Inspired Words and are received as canon.

The mismatch is not mysterious. The Church has kept the biblical word and changed the office underneath it. Members then have to perform a quiet redefinition: “prophet” now means “the man who holds the keys and presides,” not “one who prophesies.” Investigators are not told that the definition changed. They only feel the gap.

There is a second confusion inside the Church. If only one living person is “the prophet,” then sons and daughters who prophesy become an embarrassment. Dreams and impressions have to be fenced off as private and unofficial. Paul’s counsel becomes hard to read aloud. The title that should have remained common becomes a monopoly.

Class 3 custom is not a small thing here

Calling the President “the prophet” is Class 3 custom. It is later usage. It is widespread. It is not D&C 107.

Class 3 custom has power because it trains the ear. Once the ear is trained, members hear every presidential statement as if it were Class 1. That is how commentary begins to sit on top of canon. The papers on Adam-God and divine sonship exist because that habit has already done damage. A later synthesis was treated as if it had the same weight as “saith the Lord.” The cure is not contempt for leaders. The cure is to put the titles back where the revelation put them.

The President of the High Priesthood may prophesy. He may receive revelation for the Church. If he does, the Church has a way to recognize it: the voice of the Lord, a clear revelatory account, and the consent of the Church when it is to become canon. None of that requires us to rename the office.

What following D&C 107:64–65 would look like

It would look surprisingly modest.

This does not reduce the President’s keys. D&C 107 gives him presidency over the priesthood. It does not give later generations permission to collapse every biblical word for revelation into that one chair.

The real issue

The question is not whether the Church has a living head. It does. The question is whether we will let Human Words overwrite Divine Words.

D&C 107:64–65 is not obscure. It is not metaphorical. It tells the Church what to call the man appointed to preside. When members instead say “the prophet,” they are not being more faithful than the revelation. They are using a different dictionary.

A Church that hopes for more revelation should want the old words back. “President of the High Priesthood” protects the office. “Prophet” protects the gift. Keeping them distinct is not a loss of reverence. It is obedience to the text that named the office in the first place.

Have they not read the scriptures?